What four months of Google marketing taught me.
In my first four months as a mortgage broker, I spent about $2,000 on paid ads and didn't get a single enquiry from them. Asking every person I helped for a Google review has done more for me, and it hasn't cost me a cent.
I started Links Property Finance in July. It's a small brokerage in Enfield, in Sydney's Inner West, and I look after every home loan client myself, from the first call through to settlement.
Nobody online knew I existed. So I've spent the last four months trying to get found on Google, and keeping track of what it cost me. Plenty of it didn't work.
The numbers, including the bad ones
Four months in:
- About 10 enquiries a month from organic search, so people finding me without me paying for the click
- About $2,000 spent on paid ads, and zero enquiries from them
- 40 Google reviews, rated 5.0
If you're after a cost per lead for the ads, I don't have one. You can't divide $2,000 by zero. The organic enquiries haven't cost me anything in ad spend, just time, mostly on my website, my Business Profile and chasing reviews.
My first clients came through family and friends. The online enquiries took a while longer.
What didn't work, and what I did about it
I set up Google Ads about two months in, then added Microsoft Advertising a few weeks later. I didn't just switch it on and hope. I kept it to around 30 keywords on exact and phrase match, and capped clicks at $10. I added more than 40 negative keywords and turned off all 21 of Google's auto-apply settings, so nothing changed without me knowing.
My first mistake was spreading the budget too thin. I had five ad groups running: first home buyers, government schemes, guarantor loans, refinancing and the Inner West. None of them got enough clicks to tell me anything. So I paused four and kept guarantor loans going, because that's one of my main areas.
It still didn't work. Roughly $2,000 in, I hadn't had a single enquiry from an ad. Looking back, it wasn't one thing.
My website wasn't ready. I built it myself, and Google rated my landing page experience as below average. I was paying for clicks that landed on a page that wasn't doing its job.
I didn't have the reviews yet. While the ads were running I had less than half of what I have now, and most of the brokers showing up for the same searches have hundreds. When you're picking someone to help with the biggest purchase of your life, that counts.
And $2,000 doesn't go far. Finance clicks aren't cheap, and I'd split the money five ways at the start.
The bigger reason, I think, is that people don't pick a mortgage broker from an ad. It's too big a decision. They ask people they trust and they read reviews. Every one of my online enquiries has come through organic search, and not one came from an ad. I don't think that's a coincidence.
People don't pick a mortgage broker from an ad. It's too big a decision. They ask people they trust and they read reviews.
So I stopped the ads and put my time into my Google Business Profile and my reviews instead.
My Business Profile and reviews did what the ads couldn't
The Business Profile side is pretty simple. I filled in my services, added photos and put my booking link on it, so people can book a call with me straight from Google.
The reviews took real effort. I got them by pushing every single person I gave advice to for a review, including the ones who never became clients. I didn't pick and choose who to ask. For an introvert, that's a lot of asking. I'm at 40 now, with a 5.0 rating.
I can't prove the reviews are what bring in my 10 or so enquiries a month. But those enquiries all come through organic search, and when someone finds me there, my rating and review count are among the first things they see.
If you're starting out, ask everyone. Every time. It's free, and it's done more for my business than the $2,000 ever did.
I asked ChatGPT and Google who to use
I checked both in November and got two very different answers.
On Google, I searched "best first home buyer mortgage broker inner west sydney". The AI Overview at the top named five brokers. I wasn't one of them, and four of the five had somewhere between 85 and nearly 500 reviews.
ChatGPT was kinder. I asked it the same sort of question and mentioned I was in Enfield. It put Links Property Finance at the top of its list. It quoted my 5.0 rating and my 40 or so reviews, and described how I work with clients through to settlement.
What I took from it is that these tools can only repeat what they find. If your reviews are thin and your website is vague, there isn't much for them to say about you.
Where I'd start if I did it again
I'd do things in a different order:
- Get the Google Business Profile sorted first, with services, photos and a booking link.
- Ask every person I help for a review from day one.
- Fix the website, so the page people land on is actually ready.
- Leave ads until all of that is solid.
I'd also ask ChatGPT and Google about my own business on day one. It takes five minutes, and you find out exactly who you're up against.
Four months isn't long, and I'm still working a lot of this out. But the free stuff has done far more for me than the paid stuff, and I wish I'd known that before I spent the $2,000.

This article is general information only and doesn't take your personal situation into account.
Our take
Charles's numbers line up with what we see across finance and professional services. Reviews and a complete Google Business Profile are among the signals Google and AI assistants check before they recommend a local business, and ads sent to an unready landing page rarely convert in high-trust categories. His Google versus ChatGPT result is a useful reminder too: AI tools describe the businesses they can verify, so review volume and clear, consistent information compound over time. If you run a brokerage or advice business, see SEO for finance businesses, or check whether search is worth it for you with is SEO worth it?
Featured in this article?
Add this badge to your website's About or Press page. Copy the code below and paste it into an HTML or Custom Code block (WordPress, Wix, Squarespace, Webflow and Shopify all have one).
Want to be the brand AI mentions?
Intrigue Digital does SEO, AEO and GEO as one system, so your business shows up whether someone searches Google or asks ChatGPT. One business per industry, per postcode.
Book a free 15-minute site audit →Business Spotlight features are contributed by operators in our network and reflect their own experience and views. Intrigue Digital does not verify the internal metrics or figures reported and they should be read as the author's own account, not independently audited results. External studies are cited by the author.
Intrigue Digital